The new YouTube TV subscription plans promise major savings, but is the switch familiar?

Big news in streaming–YouTube TV is releasing their new genre-based subscription plans. These tiered plans are a huge shift from their previous one-size-fits all streaming model, which cost $82.99 monthly. Conversely, the cheapest of the new plans costs just $54.99 a month. This means that users can start saving on their YouTube TV subscriptions while narrowing in on what they actually want to watch. This is exciting news, but something about this streaming story feels oddly familiar. Ironically, the rollout of these new plans highlights that we may not have come as far from cable as we thought.

YouTube TV subscription Base Plan versus competition

With this new release, YouTube streaming is becoming more affordable and more customizable. Previously, the only subscription option available was the the Base Plan. This essentially gave subscribers access to everything YouTube TV  had to offer (sports, entertainment, live-streams, you name it). But the downfall of so many options is that often subscribers pay for way more than what they use. Additionally, the Base Plan price comes in steeper than their competitors that already have package options. A prime example is the DirectTV Choice Package which starts at a base price of $59.99 monthly (and has cheaper packs available). However, YouTube TV’s Base Plan comes in right around some of their competitor’s most comprehensive plan prices, as shown below:

FeatureYouTube TVDIRECTV StreamHulu + Live TVSling TV
Starting Price~$82.99/mo$89.99/mo~$99.99/mo~$60.994/mo (Orange & Blue)
Channel Count~100~185~95~50
Local ChannelsStrong nationwide (ABC, CBS, NBC, FOX)Strong, varies by regionStrong nationwideLimited (mostly FOX/NBC in select markets)
Sports CoverageESPN, FS1, RSNs varyExcellent RSN coverage; strong sports tiersESPN, FS1, some RSNsESPN (Orange), FS1 (Blue), no RSNs
Best ForBalanced channel mix + great DVRChannel‑heavy households + sports fansPeople wanting live TV + major streaming bundleBudget‑friendly cord‑cutters
Cheaper packages available?NoYesYesYes

This shows that while their Base Plan fairs well against competitors’ largest plans, YouTube TV has still been at a disadvantage by not having different options available. The launch of the new tiered plans fixes these issues. 

Layout for the new YouTube TV subscription plans

By choosing the category which best fits your preferences, you can save money and still watch all your favorites. That being said, if you still prefer the whole enchilada or are just chronically indecisive (I get it), don’t worry — the original plan will still be an option. But for those excited about the new categories, here are five confirmed of the 10+ plans YouTube TV has promised:

Plan TierMonthly PriceBest ForIncluded Content Focus
Entertainment Plan$54.99Budget-conscious viewersCore entertainment, sitcoms, and movies
Sports Plan$64.99Die-hard sports fansLive games, national broadcasting (e.g., NBC), and athletics
News, Ent. & Family$69.99Multi-viewer householdsBalanced mix of kids’ shows, daily news, and entertainment
Sports & News$71.99The informed fanComprehensive live sports coverage and global news networks
The Base Plan$82.99The “whole enchilada”All-inclusive access to every genre and channel

Major savings (with even bigger discounts for new users) and genre-specific categories is not all that’s new. YouTube TV streamers will have the option to customize their bundled plans even further with extra add-ons. Flexibility will be as big of a selling point for the new model as it is in watching your favorite gymnastics routine in the next LA28 Olympics. (I know that’s looking ahead, but aren’t we missing the Olympics already?) Plus, it’s a great example of something you could watch through the Sports plan subscription which offers national broadcasting through affiliates like NBC.

So are the YouTube TV subscription plans all that?

There’s no argument against this being a big improvement for YouTube TV subscribers. The customizable elements of these new plans truly are inspired. But one has to admit that the overarching idea isn’t necessarily unique. After all, the concept of saving money by only paying for selective entertainment is nothing new, nor is the convenience of choosing what you specifically want to watch when you want to watch it. In fact–it’s kind of what streaming is all about.

While it’s not a perfect parallel, there is a strong resemblance between the shift from YouTube TV’s Base plan to the new bundles and between the original shift from cable to digital streaming. Users are opting to pay less money for greater control over their media. Importantly, they are doing so even at the loss of sheer volume of content.

What’s funny is that if this launch is considered somewhat repetitive, no one seemed to notice the shift “backwards” in streaming trends. Perhaps traditional cable was overly demonized by the streaming movement. This is especially possible being that some of its weaknesses (like paying for content you don’t use) have persisted. YouTube TV prices were even becoming comparable with cable prices. This is not to discredit the value of streaming or YouTube TV’s Base model, but it is worth noting. Either way, the new plans seem to be a nudge back in the right direction.

And you’ve got to hand it to them, with their current discounts the YouTube TV offers are tempting. YouTube will also continue building momentum and anticipation by releasing their plan options over the course of several weeks, with many of the plans yet to be revealed. This is a strategy to keep the conversation going, which in this day and age is hard to do. Overall, the launch of the new YouTube TV subscription plans really is big news, even if it feels more like rediscovery than anything revolutionary.